The Subway Series, an iconic New York City rivalry, has seen its fair share of memorable moments and outstanding performances over the years. As we celebrate the 30th anniversary of this interleague showdown, it's time to reflect on the players who have left their mark on this historic series. Here's a look at the best Subway Series performers, with a focus on those who have excelled in this unique matchup.
Catcher: Mike Piazza, Mets
Mike Piazza dominated the Yankees with a .317 batting average, .398 on-base percentage, and an impressive .554 slugging percentage in 38 games. His performance was particularly notable during the 1999-2002 period, where he hit .366 with eight home runs in 23 games. A memorable moment came in 2000 when he clubbed a grand slam off Roger Clemens, setting the stage for a chaotic series.
First Base: Mark Teixeira, Yankees
Mark Teixeira had a competitive edge over the Mets, especially in his later career. In April 2015, he hit three homers in a series, showcasing his power. A memorable moment occurred in 2015 when he scored from first base on Luis Castillo's dropped popup, demonstrating his speed and awareness.
Second Base: Jeff McNeil, Mets
Jeff McNeil's .336 batting average in 34 games is impressive, especially considering he struggled in the Subway Series in 2022. His performance in 2021, where he went 9-for-18, is a testament to his consistency. A highlight was his go-ahead home run in the seventh inning of the 2021 series opener.
Third Base: Alex Rodríguez, Yankees
Alex Rodríguez's performance in 2005, with 14 hits in 23 at-bats, is remarkable. His 2006 season series was a tight call, but his seven-RBI performance in the finale stands out. Rodríguez's on-base percentage gives him the edge over David Wright.
Shortstop: Derek Jeter, Yankees
Derek Jeter's 87 games and 398 plate appearances in the Subway Series are unparalleled. His .364 batting average and 13 home runs are impressive, especially considering his career marks. A memorable moment was his leadoff home run against Bobby Jones in the 2000 World Series.
Left Field: Curtis Granderson, Mets and Yankees
Curtis Granderson's split time in both teams' dugouts is unique. He performed better with the Mets, with a .955 OPS, compared to .823 with the Yankees. A memorable moment was his homers in his first two games against the Yankees after joining the Mets in 2014.
Center Field: Bernie Williams, Yankees
Bernie Williams had a metronomic approach against the Mets, with a .313 batting average. His performance in the 2000 World Series, where he homered early and caught the final out, is iconic.
Right Field: Aaron Judge, Yankees
Aaron Judge's 14 home runs in the series are the most by any player. His performance in 2021, with two home runs, including the game-tying one, is a testament to his power. Judge has bludgeoned the Mets as much as any other team in recent years.
Designated Hitter: Hideki Matsui, Yankees
Hideki Matsui's OPS is topped only by Aaron Judge and Francisco Lindor. His three-run homer in the 2000 World Series against Al Leiter is a memorable moment. Matsui's performance against the Mets was consistently strong.
Pinch Hitter: Matt Franco, Mets
Matt Franco's game-winning single off Mariano Rivera in 1999 is a legendary moment. His overall pinch-hitting record against the Yankees is solid, but his two RBIs in that game are unforgettable.
Left-handed Starter: Oliver Pérez, Mets
Oliver Pérez's 4-0 record and 1.50 ERA in four starts against the Yankees are remarkable. His performance in 2008, with 7 1/3 innings of one-run ball, helped the Mets split the series and embark on a winning streak.
Right-handed Starter: A.J. Burnett, Yankees
A.J. Burnett's seven shutout innings in two starts in June 2009 are memorable. His 1.33 ERA in the Subway Series is impressive, considering his career averages.
Closer: Mariano Rivera, Yankees
Mariano Rivera's dominance against the Mets is well-documented. His 20 saves and 3.53 ERA in 34 games are impressive. A memorable moment was his bases-loaded walk against Francisco Rodríguez, showcasing his clutch performance.
